Success Stories

Pharmaceutical

Kiara Health – where SCIENCE meets NEED


Read the Success Story below


Kiara Health – Implementation of a 5 phased control system upgrade

Implementation of a 5 phased control system upgrade incorporating AVEVA Flex in a cloud based infrastructure to assist in driving Kiara Health’s mission to restore, preserve and advance the health of patients, and ultimately to progress African healthcare.

Background

Kiara Health is an African pharmaceutical manufacturing and healthcare solutions company, headquartered in Johannesburg, South Africa. It serves as the local, non-exclusive manufacturing partner for a Global Top 5 pharmaceutical company and as a commercial partner for several global pharmaceutical and medical technology companies.

Kiara Health differentiates itself within the highly competitive African healthcare landscape by offering unique healthcare solutions and medical technologies to select high-growth countries to cater to unmet needs. Offerings include robotics, medical devices, and point-of-care (POC) diagnostics, as well as innovator and generic medicines, and over the counter (OTC) products.

Business Challenges

Due to the limitations of its existing legacy monitoring and control infrastructure, Kiara Health required an upgrade strategy.

Specifically, the following problem areas were identified:

  • Multiple independent monitoring systems coupled with aging and inefficient machinery: the multiple vendor applications being utilised for the environmental monitoring and building management systems provided only limited visibility, notification capability, and increased energy usage due to several HVAC systems approaching end of life and intermittently failing motors.
  • Compliance: legacy applications were only compatible with operating systems with completed life cycles, which made it difficult to comply with the mandatory GAMP and CFR21 Part 11 requirements.
  • Communication failures and loss of data: unstable redundancy and store-forward capability was resulting in intermittent data loss.
  • Limited expansion capability with legacy equipment: the current EMS monitoring system had reached capacity resulting in key operational equipment not being monitored, as well as limiting continuous improvement projects since data was not readily available.

 

Kiara embarked on an upgrade strategy that focused on three major areas:

  • Replace aging field hardware with more efficient equipment.
  • Install a reliable control system to provide an integrated field architecture.
  • Provide a supervisory control and data acquisition with more than just SCADA capability.

All proposed solutions were to meet stringent acceptance criteria set out by Kiara, with emphasis on ‘keeping an eye on the future’.

 

Kiara, decided on the following to address the requirements for efficiency, reliability, and validation:

  • Efficiency: WEG motors and VSDs would replace aging equipment.
  • Reliability: A control system based on the S7-1500 range of PLC’s, ET200MP/PN and ET200 ECO/PN units.
  • Validation: for the SCADA system, the AVEVA Software Portfolio was investigated, and it was found that it could quickly address the immediate need for IT compliance considering the current capabilities of the sites then owned 2012R2 System Platform installation.

The Kiara engineering team showed great enthusiasm for the deployment of the project. Phases 1 and 2 were implemented during a December shutdown, which laid the backbone to support the subsequent extensions achieved during phases 3, 4 and 5.

Phase 1 – Installation of AVEVA System Platform.
Phase 2 – Exchanging older drives and motors for more energy efficient WEG VSD/motor combinations.
Phase 3 – Visualisation utilising AVEVA OMI.
Phase 4 – Historization of BMS data utilised on AVEVA OMI.
Phase 5 – Implementation of AVEVA Flex Model software architecture capabilities within a cloud environment.

 

Results of the upgrade

  • Centralised Monitoring System: Room, building, production and notification systems integrated into one centralized AVEVA System Platform.
  • Compliance: Strict installation and operational qualifications, passed by the head of Quality Assurance, ensuring CFR21 Part 11 compliance.
  • Software Lifespan: Implementation of the latest AVEVA Flex Model ensures that software is always up to date, supported and expandable for the foreseeable future.
  • Hardware Lifespan: Installation of the latest Siemens S7-1500 CPUs allows a 10-15 Year CPU lifecycle.
  • Data Loss Reduction: AVEVA System Platforms installation in a cloud environment allows for better disaster recovery capabilities and reduces system downtime previously required during hardware maintenance. Applying AVEVA’s Historian store-forward capabilities in strategic locations has reduced the risk of data loss.
  • Expansion: the AVEVA Flex Model has provided an unlimited licencing model which accelerates expansion capabilities.
  • Data Availability: the AVEVA Flex Model allows an unlimited number of supervisory clients. Used with Intouch Access Anywhere and AVEVA Insight, this allows site personnel to evaluate data on any device at any time.
  • Drive/Motor Efficiency: Replacement of existing HVAC drives and motors with the energy efficient WEG combinations created operational cost savings more than R100 000 per month.

AVEVA System Platform’s ability to seamlessly transition to a cloud-based infrastructure during the COVID-19 pandemic contributed to Kiara Health being the first and only customer on the African continent with a fully scaled server deployed in the Azure Cloud. This is the course of action that most companies are soon to follow, and it is a great accomplishment for Kiara Health, a pharmaceutical company with strict regulatory controls, to have pioneered this venture.

About Kiara Health

Kiara Health (Pty) Ltd is an African pharmaceutical manufacturing and healthcare solutions company headquartered in Johannesburg, South Africa. It serves as the local, non-exclusive manufacturing partner for a Global, Top 5 pharmaceutical company and as a commercial partner for several global pharmaceutical and medical technology companies.

Success Stories

Pharmaceutical

Kiara Health – where SCIENCE meets NEED


Read the Success Story below


Kiara Health – Implementation of a 5 phased control system upgrade

Implementation of a 5 phased control system upgrade incorporating AVEVA Flex in a cloud based infrastructure to assist in driving Kiara Health’s mission to restore, preserve and advance the health of patients, and ultimately to progress African healthcare.

Background

Kiara Health is an African pharmaceutical manufacturing and healthcare solutions company, headquartered in Johannesburg, South Africa. It serves as the local, non-exclusive manufacturing partner for a Global Top 5 pharmaceutical company and as a commercial partner for several global pharmaceutical and medical technology companies.

Kiara Health differentiates itself within the highly competitive African healthcare landscape by offering unique healthcare solutions and medical technologies to select high-growth countries to cater to unmet needs. Offerings include robotics, medical devices, and point-of-care (POC) diagnostics, as well as innovator and generic medicines, and over the counter (OTC) products.

Business Challenges

Due to the limitations of its existing legacy monitoring and control infrastructure, Kiara Health required an upgrade strategy.

Specifically, the following problem areas were identified:

  • Multiple independent monitoring systems coupled with aging and inefficient machinery: the multiple vendor applications being utilised for the environmental monitoring and building management systems provided only limited visibility, notification capability, and increased energy usage due to several HVAC systems approaching end of life and intermittently failing motors.
  • Compliance: legacy applications were only compatible with operating systems with completed life cycles, which made it difficult to comply with the mandatory GAMP and CFR21 Part 11 requirements.
  • Communication failures and loss of data: unstable redundancy and store-forward capability was resulting in intermittent data loss.
  • Limited expansion capability with legacy equipment: the current EMS monitoring system had reached capacity resulting in key operational equipment not being monitored, as well as limiting continuous improvement projects since data was not readily available.

 

Kiara embarked on an upgrade strategy that focused on three major areas:

  • Replace aging field hardware with more efficient equipment.
  • Install a reliable control system to provide an integrated field architecture.
  • Provide a supervisory control and data acquisition with more than just SCADA capability.

All proposed solutions were to meet stringent acceptance criteria set out by Kiara, with emphasis on ‘keeping an eye on the future’.

 

Kiara, decided on the following to address the requirements for efficiency, reliability, and validation:

  • Efficiency: WEG motors and VSDs would replace aging equipment.
  • Reliability: A control system based on the S7-1500 range of PLC’s, ET200MP/PN and ET200 ECO/PN units.
  • Validation: for the SCADA system, the AVEVA Software Portfolio was investigated, and it was found that it could quickly address the immediate need for IT compliance considering the current capabilities of the sites then owned 2012R2 System Platform installation.

The Kiara engineering team showed great enthusiasm for the deployment of the project. Phases 1 and 2 were implemented during a December shutdown, which laid the backbone to support the subsequent extensions achieved during phases 3, 4 and 5.

Phase 1 – Installation of AVEVA System Platform.
Phase 2 – Exchanging older drives and motors for more energy efficient WEG VSD/motor combinations.
Phase 3 – Visualisation utilising AVEVA OMI.
Phase 4 – Historization of BMS data utilised on AVEVA OMI.
Phase 5 – Implementation of AVEVA Flex Model software architecture capabilities within a cloud environment.

 

Results of the upgrade

  • Centralised Monitoring System: Room, building, production and notification systems integrated into one centralized AVEVA System Platform.
  • Compliance: Strict installation and operational qualifications, passed by the head of Quality Assurance, ensuring CFR21 Part 11 compliance.
  • Software Lifespan: Implementation of the latest AVEVA Flex Model ensures that software is always up to date, supported and expandable for the foreseeable future.
  • Hardware Lifespan: Installation of the latest Siemens S7-1500 CPUs allows a 10-15 Year CPU lifecycle.
  • Data Loss Reduction: AVEVA System Platforms installation in a cloud environment allows for better disaster recovery capabilities and reduces system downtime previously required during hardware maintenance. Applying AVEVA’s Historian store-forward capabilities in strategic locations has reduced the risk of data loss.
  • Expansion: the AVEVA Flex Model has provided an unlimited licencing model which accelerates expansion capabilities.
  • Data Availability: the AVEVA Flex Model allows an unlimited number of supervisory clients. Used with Intouch Access Anywhere and AVEVA Insight, this allows site personnel to evaluate data on any device at any time.
  • Drive/Motor Efficiency: Replacement of existing HVAC drives and motors with the energy efficient WEG combinations created operational cost savings more than R100 000 per month.

AVEVA System Platform’s ability to seamlessly transition to a cloud-based infrastructure during the COVID-19 pandemic contributed to Kiara Health being the first and only customer on the African continent with a fully scaled server deployed in the Azure Cloud. This is the course of action that most companies are soon to follow, and it is a great accomplishment for Kiara Health, a pharmaceutical company with strict regulatory controls, to have pioneered this venture.

About Kiara Health

Kiara Health (Pty) Ltd is an African pharmaceutical manufacturing and healthcare solutions company headquartered in Johannesburg, South Africa. It serves as the local, non-exclusive manufacturing partner for a Global, Top 5 pharmaceutical company and as a commercial partner for several global pharmaceutical and medical technology companies.

Experience the Limitless Potential of Technology

We love seeing our customers succeed. On the road to excellence, their success is ours. Find out how AVEVA software solutions from IS³ are helping companies all over the world to work better, faster and greener – all while reducing costs.

IS³’s Customer Success Stories

AECI Mining Explosives – Raw Material and Product Tracking
AECI Mining Explosives – Raw Material and Product Tracking
AEL (now AECI Mining Explosives) gives its customers a bigger bang for their buck with help from IS³

Speak to an Expert

Contact one of our highly qualified sales representatives to see how we can assist with maximising your potential!

    +27
    • United States+1
    • United Kingdom+44
    • Afghanistan (‫افغانستان‬‎)+93
    • Albania (Shqipëri)+355
    • Algeria (‫الجزائر‬‎)+213
    • American Samoa+1684
    • Andorra+376
    • Angola+244
    • Anguilla+1264
    • Antigua and Barbuda+1268
    • Argentina+54
    • Armenia (Հայաստան)+374
    • Aruba+297
    • Australia+61
    • Austria (Österreich)+43
    • Azerbaijan (Azərbaycan)+994
    • Bahamas+1242
    • Bahrain (‫البحرين‬‎)+973
    • Bangladesh (বাংলাদেশ)+880
    • Barbados+1246
    • Belarus (Беларусь)+375
    • Belgium (België)+32
    • Belize+501
    • Benin (Bénin)+229
    • Bermuda+1441
    • Bhutan (འབྲུག)+975
    • Bolivia+591
    • Bosnia and Herzegovina (Босна и Херцеговина)+387
    • Botswana+267
    • Brazil (Brasil)+55
    • British Indian Ocean Territory+246
    • British Virgin Islands+1284
    • Brunei+673
    • Bulgaria (България)+359
    • Burkina Faso+226
    • Burundi (Uburundi)+257
    • Cambodia (កម្ពុជា)+855
    • Cameroon (Cameroun)+237
    • Canada+1
    • Cape Verde (Kabu Verdi)+238
    • Caribbean Netherlands+599
    • Cayman Islands+1345
    • Central African Republic (République centrafricaine)+236
    • Chad (Tchad)+235
    • Chile+56
    • China (中国)+86
    • Christmas Island+61
    • Cocos (Keeling) Islands+61
    • Colombia+57
    • Comoros (‫جزر القمر‬‎)+269
    • Congo (DRC) (Jamhuri ya Kidemokrasia ya Kongo)+243
    • Congo (Republic) (Congo-Brazzaville)+242
    • Cook Islands+682
    • Costa Rica+506
    • Côte d’Ivoire+225
    • Croatia (Hrvatska)+385
    • Cuba+53
    • Curaçao+599
    • Cyprus (Κύπρος)+357
    • Czech Republic (Česká republika)+420
    • Denmark (Danmark)+45
    • Djibouti+253
    • Dominica+1767
    • Dominican Republic (República Dominicana)+1
    • Ecuador+593
    • Egypt (‫مصر‬‎)+20
    • El Salvador+503
    • Equatorial Guinea (Guinea Ecuatorial)+240
    • Eritrea+291
    • Estonia (Eesti)+372
    • Ethiopia+251
    • Falkland Islands (Islas Malvinas)+500
    • Faroe Islands (Føroyar)+298
    • Fiji+679
    • Finland (Suomi)+358
    • France+33
    • French Guiana (Guyane française)+594
    • French Polynesia (Polynésie française)+689
    • Gabon+241
    • Gambia+220
    • Georgia (საქართველო)+995
    • Germany (Deutschland)+49
    • Ghana (Gaana)+233
    • Gibraltar+350
    • Greece (Ελλάδα)+30
    • Greenland (Kalaallit Nunaat)+299
    • Grenada+1473
    • Guadeloupe+590
    • Guam+1671
    • Guatemala+502
    • Guernsey+44
    • Guinea (Guinée)+224
    • Guinea-Bissau (Guiné Bissau)+245
    • Guyana+592
    • Haiti+509
    • Honduras+504
    • Hong Kong (香港)+852
    • Hungary (Magyarország)+36
    • Iceland (Ísland)+354
    • India (भारत)+91
    • Indonesia+62
    • Iran (‫ایران‬‎)+98
    • Iraq (‫العراق‬‎)+964
    • Ireland+353
    • Isle of Man+44
    • Israel (‫ישראל‬‎)+972
    • Italy (Italia)+39
    • Jamaica+1
    • Japan (日本)+81
    • Jersey+44
    • Jordan (‫الأردن‬‎)+962
    • Kazakhstan (Казахстан)+7
    • Kenya+254
    • Kiribati+686
    • Kosovo+383
    • Kuwait (‫الكويت‬‎)+965
    • Kyrgyzstan (Кыргызстан)+996
    • Laos (ລາວ)+856
    • Latvia (Latvija)+371
    • Lebanon (‫لبنان‬‎)+961
    • Lesotho+266
    • Liberia+231
    • Libya (‫ليبيا‬‎)+218
    • Liechtenstein+423
    • Lithuania (Lietuva)+370
    • Luxembourg+352
    • Macau (澳門)+853
    • Macedonia (FYROM) (Македонија)+389
    • Madagascar (Madagasikara)+261
    • Malawi+265
    • Malaysia+60
    • Maldives+960
    • Mali+223
    • Malta+356
    • Marshall Islands+692
    • Martinique+596
    • Mauritania (‫موريتانيا‬‎)+222
    • Mauritius (Moris)+230
    • Mayotte+262
    • Mexico (México)+52
    • Micronesia+691
    • Moldova (Republica Moldova)+373
    • Monaco+377
    • Mongolia (Монгол)+976
    • Montenegro (Crna Gora)+382
    • Montserrat+1664
    • Morocco (‫المغرب‬‎)+212
    • Mozambique (Moçambique)+258
    • Myanmar (Burma) (မြန်မာ)+95
    • Namibia (Namibië)+264
    • Nauru+674
    • Nepal (नेपाल)+977
    • Netherlands (Nederland)+31
    • New Caledonia (Nouvelle-Calédonie)+687
    • New Zealand+64
    • Nicaragua+505
    • Niger (Nijar)+227
    • Nigeria+234
    • Niue+683
    • Norfolk Island+672
    • North Korea (조선 민주주의 인민 공화국)+850
    • Northern Mariana Islands+1670
    • Norway (Norge)+47
    • Oman (‫عُمان‬‎)+968
    • Pakistan (‫پاکستان‬‎)+92
    • Palau+680
    • Palestine (‫فلسطين‬‎)+970
    • Panama (Panamá)+507
    • Papua New Guinea+675
    • Paraguay+595
    • Peru (Perú)+51
    • Philippines+63
    • Poland (Polska)+48
    • Portugal+351
    • Puerto Rico+1
    • Qatar (‫قطر‬‎)+974
    • Réunion (La Réunion)+262
    • Romania (România)+40
    • Russia (Россия)+7
    • Rwanda+250
    • Saint Barthélemy+590
    • Saint Helena+290
    • Saint Kitts and Nevis+1869
    • Saint Lucia+1758
    • Saint Martin (Saint-Martin (partie française))+590
    • Saint Pierre and Miquelon (Saint-Pierre-et-Miquelon)+508
    • Saint Vincent and the Grenadines+1784
    • Samoa+685
    • San Marino+378
    • São Tomé and Príncipe (São Tomé e Príncipe)+239
    • Saudi Arabia (‫المملكة العربية السعودية‬‎)+966
    • Senegal (Sénégal)+221
    • Serbia (Србија)+381
    • Seychelles+248
    • Sierra Leone+232
    • Singapore+65
    • Sint Maarten+1721
    • Slovakia (Slovensko)+421
    • Slovenia (Slovenija)+386
    • Solomon Islands+677
    • Somalia (Soomaaliya)+252
    • South Africa+27
    • South Korea (대한민국)+82
    • South Sudan (‫جنوب السودان‬‎)+211
    • Spain (España)+34
    • Sri Lanka (ශ්‍රී ලංකාව)+94
    • Sudan (‫السودان‬‎)+249
    • Suriname+597
    • Svalbard and Jan Mayen+47
    • Swaziland+268
    • Sweden (Sverige)+46
    • Switzerland (Schweiz)+41
    • Syria (‫سوريا‬‎)+963
    • Taiwan (台灣)+886
    • Tajikistan+992
    • Tanzania+255
    • Thailand (ไทย)+66
    • Timor-Leste+670
    • Togo+228
    • Tokelau+690
    • Tonga+676
    • Trinidad and Tobago+1868
    • Tunisia (‫تونس‬‎)+216
    • Turkey (Türkiye)+90
    • Turkmenistan+993
    • Turks and Caicos Islands+1649
    • Tuvalu+688
    • U.S. Virgin Islands+1340
    • Uganda+256
    • Ukraine (Україна)+380
    • United Arab Emirates (‫الإمارات العربية المتحدة‬‎)+971
    • United Kingdom+44
    • United States+1
    • Uruguay+598
    • Uzbekistan (Oʻzbekiston)+998
    • Vanuatu+678
    • Vatican City (Città del Vaticano)+39
    • Venezuela+58
    • Vietnam (Việt Nam)+84
    • Wallis and Futuna (Wallis-et-Futuna)+681
    • Western Sahara (‫الصحراء الغربية‬‎)+212
    • Yemen (‫اليمن‬‎)+967
    • Zambia+260
    • Zimbabwe+263
    • Åland Islands+358

    Success Stories

    Mining, Metals and Minerals

    Exxaro Grootegeluk

    Read the success story below

    Supervising the supervisory system at Exxaro’s Grootegeluk coal mine

    Goals

    • Expert, remote supervision of the mine’s industrial automation infrastructure
    • Detection of system issues before they can cause major downtime
    • Automatic notification of potential problems
    • Maintain system health and performance
    • Management of software updates and patches

    Solutions and Products

    • Sentinel Services
    • System Platform
    • Historian
    • Information Server
    • InTouch

    Challenges

    • Accepting the concept of remote system supervision without jeopardising security

    Results

    • 24/7/365 proactive system monitoring
    • 82% reduction in monthly system issues
    • Improved system availability
    • Availability of expert resources
    • System software is always current
    • Maximised asset ROI
    • Documented reasons for system improvement
    • Peace of mind

    Lephalale, Limpopo Province, South Africa

    Apart from capable personnel at all levels, Exxaro’s extensive Grootegeluk coal mine relies on a large industrial automation infrastructure to look after and control its complex coal beneficiation processes. But who’s looking after that vital infrastructure?

    About Exxaro’s Grootegeluk coal mine

    Situated 25 km from Lephalale in South Africa’s Limpopo province, this openpit mine employs 2100 people and produces 18,8 Mtpa final coal products, using a conventional truck and shovel operation. This mine has an estimated minable coal reserve of 2800Mt and a total measured coal resource of 4600Mt, from which semi-soft coking coal, thermal coal and metallurgical coal can be produced.

    Grootegeluk has the world’s largest beneficiation complex where 8000 tonnes per hour of run-of-mine coal is upgraded in eight different plants.

    Background

    The complexity and sophistication of supervisory and control systems is growing at a steady rate to keep up with the need for production information and efficiency. At the same time, these systems need access to sensors and instrumentation through equally sophisticated PLCs so that they can log, measure and control events in real time. So we can say without exaggeration that industrial automation and industrial IT is not for the faint-hearted. In fact, a “data processing manager” of the latter half of last century would pale when considering what instrumentation engineers, production managers and others have to deal with today – because even he wouldn’t know what was going on.

    That’s why it’s become vital to find people that could integrate production knowledge with system knowledge – such a person is Jacques Jansen, Solution Analyst, Automation, Exxaro Grootegeluk. He makes a point that, although they have a great knowledge of their industrial automation infrastructure (Exxaro implemented their systems with minimal assistance from system integrators), their expertise lies in coal beneficiation and not in the quirks of the latest operating system or monitoring scan overruns.

    “One of the biggest problems we have in the automation environment has to do with changes,” says Jansen. “While everything seems to be operating well with a stable system, someone could have justifiably changed a system parameter whose effect isn’t immediately obvious but that eventually results in a problem over time. We don’t have the resources and skills on site to deal with such problems.”

    Another change is the issue of system updates where IT personnel would update existing operating systems without regard as to what updates and patches were in place.

    “All these changes would slow down the systems and even cause expensive downtime leaving the operators to ask for help,” says Jansen. “We’re looking to expand our operations in the Waterberg but with skills and resources becoming scarcer and technicians stretched to their limit looking after the plant, we decided to look for a proactive system monitoring tool that could detect issues before they cause downtime.”

     

    Implementation
    The implementation took place between January and February 2013 and included installing monitoring agents at each key node of the system. The first priority was to establish secure internet remote access through a dedicated port with only one-way traffic. Next on the agenda was a system assessment which included a system health audit followed by recommendations from IS³ and a stabilisation project.

    “The system assessment revealed a number of issues such as excessive disc and CPU usage, scan overruns, exceeding best-practice thresholds and several other problems which first had to be addressed before routine monitoring could begin,” says Jansen. “Apart from the real-time alerts from the AVEVA software provided by IS³, we also meet once a month to go through an extensive report not only to discuss what happened but also to look at developments and recommendations as to where we should be heading. This is a very thorough report. We saw problems with the number of alarms operators were required to handle and we even detected an error in the configuration on a virtual machine that caused things to slow down unacceptably. These meetings help us to optimise the software life cycle, upgrade our roadmap for the future and review our alarming and security philosophies.”

    Success Stories

    Mining, Metals and Minerals

    Exxaro Grootegeluk

    Read the success story below

    Supervising the supervisory system at Exxaro’s Grootegeluk coal mine

    Goals

    • Expert, remote supervision of the mine’s industrial automation infrastructure
    • Detection of system issues before they can cause major downtime
    • Automatic notification of potential problems
    • Maintain system health and performance
    • Management of software updates and patches

    Solutions and Products

    • Sentinel Services
    • System Platform
    • Historian
    • Information Server
    • InTouch

    Challenges

    • Accepting the concept of remote system supervision without jeopardising security

    Results

    • 24/7/365 proactive system monitoring
    • 82% reduction in monthly system issues
    • Improved system availability
    • Availability of expert resources
    • System software is always current
    • Maximised asset ROI
    • Documented reasons for system improvement
    • Peace of mind

    Lephalale, Limpopo Province, South Africa

    Apart from capable personnel at all levels, Exxaro’s extensive Grootegeluk coal mine relies on a large industrial automation infrastructure to look after and control its complex coal beneficiation processes. But who’s looking after that vital infrastructure?

    The Intelligence Analytics Client is essentially the authoring tool for dashboard visualisation. But it’s more than that; it’s a “Self-service” analytical tool that is so powerful that I believe everyone should have it on their desktop. Throw away spreadsheets and put this on your desktop – it’s incredible!”

    Graeme Welton, Director, Advansys (Pty) Ltd.

    Background

    The complexity and sophistication of supervisory and control systems is growing at a steady rate to keep up with the need for production information and efficiency. At the same time, these systems need access to sensors and instrumentation through equally sophisticated PLCs so that they can log, measure and control events in real time. So we can say without exaggeration that industrial automation and industrial IT is not for the faint-hearted. In fact, a “data processing manager” of the latter half of last century would pale when considering what instrumentation engineers, production managers and others have to deal with today – because even he wouldn’t know what was going on.

    That’s why it’s become vital to find people that could integrate production knowledge with system knowledge – such a person is Jacques Jansen, Solution Analyst, Automation, Exxaro Grootegeluk. He makes a point that, although they have a great knowledge of their industrial automation infrastructure (Exxaro implemented their systems with minimal assistance from system integrators), their expertise lies in coal beneficiation and not in the quirks of the latest operating system or monitoring scan overruns.

    “One of the biggest problems we have in the automation environment has to do with changes,” says Jansen. “While everything seems to be operating well with a stable system, someone could have justifiably changed a system parameter whose effect isn’t immediately obvious but that eventually results in a problem over time. We don’t have the resources and skills on site to deal with such problems.”

    Another change is the issue of system updates where IT personnel would update existing operating systems without regard as to what updates and patches were in place.

    “All these changes would slow down the systems and even cause expensive downtime leaving the operators to ask for help,” says Jansen. “We’re looking to expand our operations in the Waterberg but with skills and resources becoming scarcer and technicians stretched to their limit looking after the plant, we decided to look for a proactive system monitoring tool that could detect issues before they cause downtime.”

     

    Implementation
    The implementation took place between January and February 2013 and included installing monitoring agents at each key node of the system. The first priority was to establish secure internet remote access through a dedicated port with only one-way traffic. Next on the agenda was a system assessment which included a system health audit followed by recommendations from IS³ and a stabilisation project.

    “The system assessment revealed a number of issues such as excessive disc and CPU usage, scan overruns, exceeding best-practice thresholds and several other problems which first had to be addressed before routine monitoring could begin,” says Jansen. “Apart from the real-time alerts from the AVEVA software provided by IS³, we also meet once a month to go through an extensive report not only to discuss what happened but also to look at developments and recommendations as to where we should be heading. This is a very thorough report. We saw problems with the number of alarms operators were required to handle and we even detected an error in the configuration on a virtual machine that caused things to slow down unacceptably. These meetings help us to optimise the software life cycle, upgrade our roadmap for the future and review our alarming and security philosophies.”

    Implementation

    Exxaro selected AVEVA-endorsed system integrator Advansys (Pty) Ltd for the project because the company has manufacturing systems experts and, more to the point for this project, business intelligence specialists.

    “AVEVA Intelligence provides a dimensioned data model. For example we can reference plant area, material, planned or actual production values and any number of other dimensions. It also has a CSV plug-in which we use to download the daily plan from the mine planning system. But most importantly, it has dashboard-based visual analytical tools which will help personnel design their own reporting dashboards.”

    AVEVA Historian

    AVEVA Historian is a high speed, high resolution (i.e. < 1 second) and high performance data logger and database that gathers data from sensors, meters and transmitters.

     

    AVEVA Intelligence

    AVEVA Intelligence is a “real-time” data warehousing solution (dimensions and measurements). It comprises two distinct components: the first is concerned with data collection and organisation into a dimensioned model and the second is an interactive visualisation and dashboarding tool.

    “The Intelligence Analytics Client is essentially the authoring tool for dashboard visualisation. But it’s more than that; it’s a “Self-service” analytical tool that is so powerful that I believe everyone should have it on their desktop. Throw away spreadsheets and put this on your desktop – it’s incredible!” says Welton. “Visual analytics and dashboarding are extremely effective management tools because everyone is looking at the same version of the truth drawn from a single data warehouse. The interactive and visual nature of these dashboards significantly increases the speed and confidence of decision making. This functionality will be exploited in future by connecting AVEVA Intelligence to other data sources such as the AVEVA Performance solution provided by IS³.”

    Reports

    Reports can also be made available on mobile devices if required:

     

    From my point of view, one of the greatest success factors of this project is that Exxaro personnel have taken ownership of the reporting solution. Process and system engineers alike are using the system themselves with little or no involvement from us.”

    Graeme Welton, Director, Advansys (Pty) Ltd.

    Benefits

    • Greatly improved speed and confidence of near-real-time decision making
    • Single version of the truth
    • Replaced Excel as a reporting solution
    • Independence and ease of use as users can configure their own reports and dashboards – solution is also now used outside of GMEP in most of the Grootegeluk plant
    • Collation of data from multiple sources to provide a cohesive and contextual view of production
    • “Back fill” capability leverages existing Historian data allowing back-tracking as far as needed
    • Validation of all data and the ability to go back in time to correct invalid or missing manual or automatically-derived data

    What’s next?  

    The success of this project could mean that it will be expanded into the greater Grootegeluk plant. “It can possibly be used beyond production reporting in other areas such as finance or legal compliance with respect to safety and incident reporting,” says Welton. “Anything that is time-based and can be attached to a dimension inside AVEVA Intelligence can be reported with this system.” The next step is to consider Tier 2 which would entail replicating this solution at different mines and processing plants and being able to aggregate all or part of that information for head office to create a divisional reporting solution.

    Success Stories

    Mining, Metals and Minerals

    Exxaro Grootegeluk

    Read the success story below

    Supervising the supervisory system at Exxaro’s Grootegeluk coal mine

    Goals

    • Expert, remote supervision of the mine’s industrial automation infrastructure
    • Detection of system issues before they can cause major downtime
    • Automatic notification of potential problems
    • Maintain system health and performance
    • Management of software updates and patches

    Solutions and Products

    • Sentinel Services
    • System Platform
    • Historian
    • Information Server
    • InTouch

    Challenges

    • Accepting the concept of remote system supervision without jeopardising security

    Results

    • 24/7/365 proactive system monitoring
    • 82% reduction in monthly system issues
    • Improved system availability
    • Availability of expert resources
    • System software is always current
    • Maximised asset ROI
    • Documented reasons for system improvement
    • Peace of mind

    Lephalale, Limpopo Province, South Africa

    Apart from capable personnel at all levels, Exxaro’s extensive Grootegeluk coal mine relies on a large industrial automation infrastructure to look after and control its complex coal beneficiation processes. But who’s looking after that vital infrastructure?

    Success Stories

    Mining, Metals and Minerals

    Exxaro Grootegeluk

    Read the success story below

    Supervising the supervisory system at Exxaro’s Grootegeluk coal mine

    Goals

    • Expert, remote supervision of the mine’s industrial automation infrastructure
    • Detection of system issues before they can cause major downtime
    • Automatic notification of potential problems
    • Maintain system health and performance
    • Management of software updates and patches

    Solutions and Products

    • Sentinel Services
    • System Platform
    • Historian
    • Information Server
    • InTouch

    Challenges

    • Accepting the concept of remote system supervision without jeopardising security

    Results

    • 24/7/365 proactive system monitoring
    • 82% reduction in monthly system issues
    • Improved system availability
    • Availability of expert resources
    • System software is always current
    • Maximised asset ROI
    • Documented reasons for system improvement
    • Peace of mind

    Lephalale, Limpopo Province, South Africa

    Apart from capable personnel at all levels, Exxaro’s extensive Grootegeluk coal mine relies on a large industrial automation infrastructure to look after and control its complex coal beneficiation processes. But who’s looking after that vital infrastructure?

    About Exxaro’s Grootegeluk coal mine

    Situated 25 km from Lephalale in South Africa’s Limpopo province, this openpit mine employs 2100 people and produces 18,8 Mtpa final coal products, using a conventional truck and shovel operation. This mine has an estimated minable coal reserve of 2800Mt and a total measured coal resource of 4600Mt, from which semi-soft coking coal, thermal coal and metallurgical coal can be produced.

    Grootegeluk has the world’s largest beneficiation complex where 8000 tonnes per hour of run-of-mine coal is upgraded in eight different plants.

    Background

    The complexity and sophistication of supervisory and control systems is growing at a steady rate to keep up with the need for production information and efficiency. At the same time, these systems need access to sensors and instrumentation through equally sophisticated PLCs so that they can log, measure and control events in real time. So we can say without exaggeration that industrial automation and industrial IT is not for the faint-hearted. In fact, a “data processing manager” of the latter half of last century would pale when considering what instrumentation engineers, production managers and others have to deal with today – because even he wouldn’t know what was going on.

    That’s why it’s become vital to find people that could integrate production knowledge with system knowledge – such a person is Jacques Jansen, Solution Analyst, Automation, Exxaro Grootegeluk. He makes a point that, although they have a great knowledge of their industrial automation infrastructure (Exxaro implemented their systems with minimal assistance from system integrators), their expertise lies in coal beneficiation and not in the quirks of the latest operating system or monitoring scan overruns.

    “One of the biggest problems we have in the automation environment has to do with changes,” says Jansen. “While everything seems to be operating well with a stable system, someone could have justifiably changed a system parameter whose effect isn’t immediately obvious but that eventually results in a problem over time. We don’t have the resources and skills on site to deal with such problems.”

    Another change is the issue of system updates where IT personnel would update existing operating systems without regard as to what updates and patches were in place.

    “All these changes would slow down the systems and even cause expensive downtime leaving the operators to ask for help,” says Jansen. “We’re looking to expand our operations in the Waterberg but with skills and resources becoming scarcer and technicians stretched to their limit looking after the plant, we decided to look for a proactive system monitoring tool that could detect issues before they cause downtime.”

     

    Implementation
    The implementation took place between January and February 2013 and included installing monitoring agents at each key node of the system. The first priority was to establish secure internet remote access through a dedicated port with only one-way traffic. Next on the agenda was a system assessment which included a system health audit followed by recommendations from IS³ and a stabilisation project.

    “The system assessment revealed a number of issues such as excessive disc and CPU usage, scan overruns, exceeding best-practice thresholds and several other problems which first had to be addressed before routine monitoring could begin,” says Jansen. “Apart from the real-time alerts from the AVEVA software provided by IS³, we also meet once a month to go through an extensive report not only to discuss what happened but also to look at developments and recommendations as to where we should be heading. This is a very thorough report. We saw problems with the number of alarms operators were required to handle and we even detected an error in the configuration on a virtual machine that caused things to slow down unacceptably. These meetings help us to optimise the software life cycle, upgrade our roadmap for the future and review our alarming and security philosophies.”

    Exxaro Coal (Pty) Ltd

    Read the Success Success Story below

    Supervising the supervisory system at Exxaro’s Grootegeluk coal mine

    Goals

    • Expert, remote supervision of the mine’s industrial automation infrastructure
    • Detection of system issues before they can cause major downtime
    • Automatic notification of potential problems
    • Maintain system health and performance
    • Management of software updates and patches

    Solutions and Products

    • Sentinel Services
    • System Platform
    • Historian
    • Information Server
    • InTouch

    Challenges

    • Accepting the concept of remote system supervision without jeopardising security

    Results

    • 24/7/365 proactive system monitoring
    • 82% reduction in monthly system issues
    • Improved system availability
    • Availability of expert resources
    • System software is always current
    • Maximised asset ROI
    • Documented reasons for system improvement
    • Peace of mind

    Lephalale, Limpopo Province, South Africa

    Apart from capable personnel at all levels, Exxaro’s extensive Grootegeluk coal mine relies on a large industrial automation infrastructure to look after and control its complex coal beneficiation processes. But who’s looking after that vital infrastructure?

    The Intelligence Analytics Client is essentially the authoring tool for dashboard visualisation. But it’s more than that; it’s a “Self-service” analytical tool that is so powerful that I believe everyone should have it on their desktop. Throw away spreadsheets and put this on your desktop – it’s incredible!”

    Graeme Welton, Director, Advansys (Pty) Ltd.

    About Exxaro’s Grootegeluk coal mine

    Situated 25 km from Lephalale in South Africa’s Limpopo province, this openpit mine employs 2100 people and produces 18,8 Mtpa final coal products, using a conventional truck and shovel operation. This mine has an estimated minable coal reserve of 2800Mt and a total measured coal resource of 4600Mt, from which semi-soft coking coal, thermal coal and metallurgical coal can be produced.

    Grootegeluk has the world’s largest beneficiation complex where 8000 tonnes per hour of run-of-mine coal is upgraded in eight different plants.

    Background

    The complexity and sophistication of supervisory and control systems is growing at a steady rate to keep up with the need for production information and efficiency. At the same time, these systems need access to sensors and instrumentation through equally sophisticated PLCs so that they can log, measure and control events in real time. So we can say without exaggeration that industrial automation and industrial IT is not for the faint-hearted. In fact, a “data processing manager” of the latter half of last century would pale when considering what instrumentation engineers, production managers and others have to deal with today – because even he wouldn’t know what was going on.

    That’s why it’s become vital to find people that could integrate production knowledge with system knowledge – such a person is Jacques Jansen, Solution Analyst, Automation, Exxaro Grootegeluk. He makes a point that, although they have a great knowledge of their industrial automation infrastructure (Exxaro implemented their systems with minimal assistance from system integrators), their expertise lies in coal beneficiation and not in the quirks of the latest operating system or monitoring scan overruns.

    “One of the biggest problems we have in the automation environment has to do with changes,” says Jansen. “While everything seems to be operating well with a stable system, someone could have justifiably changed a system parameter whose effect isn’t immediately obvious but that eventually results in a problem over time. We don’t have the resources and skills on site to deal with such problems.”

    Another change is the issue of system updates where IT personnel would update existing operating systems without regard as to what updates and patches were in place.

    “All these changes would slow down the systems and even cause expensive downtime leaving the operators to ask for help,” says Jansen. “We’re looking to expand our operations in the Waterberg but with skills and resources becoming scarcer and technicians stretched to their limit looking after the plant, we decided to look for a proactive system monitoring tool that could detect issues before they cause downtime.”

     

    Implementation
    The implementation took place between January and February 2013 and included installing monitoring agents at each key node of the system. The first priority was to establish secure internet remote access through a dedicated port with only one-way traffic. Next on the agenda was a system assessment which included a system health audit followed by recommendations from IS³ and a stabilisation project.

    “The system assessment revealed a number of issues such as excessive disc and CPU usage, scan overruns, exceeding best-practice thresholds and several other problems which first had to be addressed before routine monitoring could begin,” says Jansen. “Apart from the real-time alerts from the AVEVA software provided by IS³, we also meet once a month to go through an extensive report not only to discuss what happened but also to look at developments and recommendations as to where we should be heading. This is a very thorough report. We saw problems with the number of alarms operators were required to handle and we even detected an error in the configuration on a virtual machine that caused things to slow down unacceptably. These meetings help us to optimise the software life cycle, upgrade our roadmap for the future and review our alarming and security philosophies.”

    Implementation

    Exxaro selected AVEVA-endorsed system integrator Advansys (Pty) Ltd for the project because the company has manufacturing systems experts and, more to the point for this project, business intelligence specialists.

    “AVEVA Intelligence provides a dimensioned data model. For example we can reference plant area, material, planned or actual production values and any number of other dimensions. It also has a CSV plug-in which we use to download the daily plan from the mine planning system. But most importantly, it has dashboard-based visual analytical tools which will help personnel design their own reporting dashboards.”

    AVEVA Historian

    AVEVA Historian is a high speed, high resolution (i.e. < 1 second) and high performance data logger and database that gathers data from sensors, meters and transmitters.

     

    AVEVA Intelligence

    AVEVA Intelligence is a “real-time” data warehousing solution (dimensions and measurements). It comprises two distinct components: the first is concerned with data collection and organisation into a dimensioned model and the second is an interactive visualisation and dashboarding tool.

    “The Intelligence Analytics Client is essentially the authoring tool for dashboard visualisation. But it’s more than that; it’s a “Self-service” analytical tool that is so powerful that I believe everyone should have it on their desktop. Throw away spreadsheets and put this on your desktop – it’s incredible!” says Welton. “Visual analytics and dashboarding are extremely effective management tools because everyone is looking at the same version of the truth drawn from a single data warehouse. The interactive and visual nature of these dashboards significantly increases the speed and confidence of decision making. This functionality will be exploited in future by connecting AVEVA Intelligence to other data sources such as the AVEVA Performance solution provided by IS³.”

    Reports

    Reports can also be made available on mobile devices if required:

     

    Success Stories

    Pharmaceutical

    Kiara Health – where SCIENCE meets NEED


    Read the Success Story below


    Supervising the supervisory system at Exxaro’s Grootegeluk coal mine

    Goals

    • Expert, remote supervision of the mine’s industrial automation infrastructure
    • Detection of system issues before they can cause major downtime
    • Automatic notification of potential problems
    • Maintain system health and performance
    • Management of software updates and patches

    Solutions and Products

    • Sentinel Services
    • System Platform
    • Historian
    • Information Server
    • InTouch

    Challenges

    • Accepting the concept of remote system supervision without jeopardising security

    Results

    • 24/7/365 proactive system monitoring
    • 82% reduction in monthly system issues
    • Improved system availability
    • Availability of expert resources
    • System software is always current
    • Maximised asset ROI
    • Documented reasons for system improvement
    • Peace of mind

    Lephalale, Limpopo Province, South Africa

    Apart from capable personnel at all levels, Exxaro’s extensive Grootegeluk coal mine relies on a large industrial automation infrastructure to look after and control its complex coal beneficiation processes. But who’s looking after that vital infrastructure?

    The Intelligence Analytics Client is essentially the authoring tool for dashboard visualisation. But it’s more than that; it’s a “Self-service” analytical tool that is so powerful that I believe everyone should have it on their desktop. Throw away spreadsheets and put this on your desktop – it’s incredible!”

    Graeme Welton, Director, Advansys (Pty) Ltd.

    About Exxaro’s Grootegeluk coal mine

    Situated 25 km from Lephalale in South Africa’s Limpopo province, this openpit mine employs 2100 people and produces 18,8 Mtpa final coal products, using a conventional truck and shovel operation. This mine has an estimated minable coal reserve of 2800Mt and a total measured coal resource of 4600Mt, from which semi-soft coking coal, thermal coal and metallurgical coal can be produced.

    Grootegeluk has the world’s largest beneficiation complex where 8000 tonnes per hour of run-of-mine coal is upgraded in eight different plants.

    Background

    The complexity and sophistication of supervisory and control systems is growing at a steady rate to keep up with the need for production information and efficiency. At the same time, these systems need access to sensors and instrumentation through equally sophisticated PLCs so that they can log, measure and control events in real time. So we can say without exaggeration that industrial automation and industrial IT is not for the faint-hearted. In fact, a “data processing manager” of the latter half of last century would pale when considering what instrumentation engineers, production managers and others have to deal with today – because even he wouldn’t know what was going on.

    That’s why it’s become vital to find people that could integrate production knowledge with system knowledge – such a person is Jacques Jansen, Solution Analyst, Automation, Exxaro Grootegeluk. He makes a point that, although they have a great knowledge of their industrial automation infrastructure (Exxaro implemented their systems with minimal assistance from system integrators), their expertise lies in coal beneficiation and not in the quirks of the latest operating system or monitoring scan overruns.

    “One of the biggest problems we have in the automation environment has to do with changes,” says Jansen. “While everything seems to be operating well with a stable system, someone could have justifiably changed a system parameter whose effect isn’t immediately obvious but that eventually results in a problem over time. We don’t have the resources and skills on site to deal with such problems.”

    Another change is the issue of system updates where IT personnel would update existing operating systems without regard as to what updates and patches were in place.

    “All these changes would slow down the systems and even cause expensive downtime leaving the operators to ask for help,” says Jansen. “We’re looking to expand our operations in the Waterberg but with skills and resources becoming scarcer and technicians stretched to their limit looking after the plant, we decided to look for a proactive system monitoring tool that could detect issues before they cause downtime.”

     

    Implementation
    The implementation took place between January and February 2013 and included installing monitoring agents at each key node of the system. The first priority was to establish secure internet remote access through a dedicated port with only one-way traffic. Next on the agenda was a system assessment which included a system health audit followed by recommendations from IS³ and a stabilisation project.

    “The system assessment revealed a number of issues such as excessive disc and CPU usage, scan overruns, exceeding best-practice thresholds and several other problems which first had to be addressed before routine monitoring could begin,” says Jansen. “Apart from the real-time alerts from the AVEVA software provided by IS³, we also meet once a month to go through an extensive report not only to discuss what happened but also to look at developments and recommendations as to where we should be heading. This is a very thorough report. We saw problems with the number of alarms operators were required to handle and we even detected an error in the configuration on a virtual machine that caused things to slow down unacceptably. These meetings help us to optimise the software life cycle, upgrade our roadmap for the future and review our alarming and security philosophies.”

    Success Stories

    Mining, Metals and Minerals

    Exxaro GMEP

    Read the success story below

    Supervising the supervisory system at Exxaro’s Grootegeluk coal mine

    Goals

    • Expert, remote supervision of the mine’s industrial automation infrastructure
    • Detection of system issues before they can cause major downtime
    • Automatic notification of potential problems
    • Maintain system health and performance
    • Management of software updates and patches

    Solutions and Products

    • Sentinel Services
    • System Platform
    • Historian
    • Information Server
    • InTouch

    Challenges

    • Accepting the concept of remote system supervision without jeopardising security

    Results

    • 24/7/365 proactive system monitoring
    • 82% reduction in monthly system issues
    • Improved system availability
    • Availability of expert resources
    • System software is always current
    • Maximised asset ROI
    • Documented reasons for system improvement
    • Peace of mind

    Lephalale, Limpopo Province, South Africa

    Apart from capable personnel at all levels, Exxaro’s extensive Grootegeluk coal mine relies on a large industrial automation infrastructure to look after and control its complex coal beneficiation processes. But who’s looking after that vital infrastructure?

    About Exxaro’s Grootegeluk coal mine

    Situated 25 km from Lephalale in South Africa’s Limpopo province, this openpit mine employs 2100 people and produces 18,8 Mtpa final coal products, using a conventional truck and shovel operation. This mine has an estimated minable coal reserve of 2800Mt and a total measured coal resource of 4600Mt, from which semi-soft coking coal, thermal coal and metallurgical coal can be produced.

    Grootegeluk has the world’s largest beneficiation complex where 8000 tonnes per hour of run-of-mine coal is upgraded in eight different plants.

    The Intelligence Analytics Client is essentially the authoring tool for dashboard visualisation. But it’s more than that; it’s a “Self-service” analytical tool that is so powerful that I believe everyone should have it on their desktop. Throw away spreadsheets and put this on your desktop – it’s incredible!”

    Graeme Welton, Director, Advansys (Pty) Ltd.

    Background

    The complexity and sophistication of supervisory and control systems is growing at a steady rate to keep up with the need for production information and efficiency. At the same time, these systems need access to sensors and instrumentation through equally sophisticated PLCs so that they can log, measure and control events in real time. So we can say without exaggeration that industrial automation and industrial IT is not for the faint-hearted. In fact, a “data processing manager” of the latter half of last century would pale when considering what instrumentation engineers, production managers and others have to deal with today – because even he wouldn’t know what was going on.

    That’s why it’s become vital to find people that could integrate production knowledge with system knowledge – such a person is Jacques Jansen, Solution Analyst, Automation, Exxaro Grootegeluk. He makes a point that, although they have a great knowledge of their industrial automation infrastructure (Exxaro implemented their systems with minimal assistance from system integrators), their expertise lies in coal beneficiation and not in the quirks of the latest operating system or monitoring scan overruns.

    “One of the biggest problems we have in the automation environment has to do with changes,” says Jansen. “While everything seems to be operating well with a stable system, someone could have justifiably changed a system parameter whose effect isn’t immediately obvious but that eventually results in a problem over time. We don’t have the resources and skills on site to deal with such problems.”

    Another change is the issue of system updates where IT personnel would update existing operating systems without regard as to what updates and patches were in place.

    “All these changes would slow down the systems and even cause expensive downtime leaving the operators to ask for help,” says Jansen. “We’re looking to expand our operations in the Waterberg but with skills and resources becoming scarcer and technicians stretched to their limit looking after the plant, we decided to look for a proactive system monitoring tool that could detect issues before they cause downtime.”

     

    Implementation
    The implementation took place between January and February 2013 and included installing monitoring agents at each key node of the system. The first priority was to establish secure internet remote access through a dedicated port with only one-way traffic. Next on the agenda was a system assessment which included a system health audit followed by recommendations from IS³ and a stabilisation project.

    “The system assessment revealed a number of issues such as excessive disc and CPU usage, scan overruns, exceeding best-practice thresholds and several other problems which first had to be addressed before routine monitoring could begin,” says Jansen. “Apart from the real-time alerts from the AVEVA software provided by IS³, we also meet once a month to go through an extensive report not only to discuss what happened but also to look at developments and recommendations as to where we should be heading. This is a very thorough report. We saw problems with the number of alarms operators were required to handle and we even detected an error in the configuration on a virtual machine that caused things to slow down unacceptably. These meetings help us to optimise the software life cycle, upgrade our roadmap for the future and review our alarming and security philosophies.”